44 replies to this topic

[THC]

Supported, Many People do something Similar in profiles. It'd be nice to see a perm item.

[Stotic]

Support.

[Pureza]

supported

[Trevayne]

I support the idea of the trophy item creation, but not the clan house addition.

Players can store their trophies in their personal vaults, and taking them in/out of the vault will show them to everyone else.

A clan room addition would (1) require programming changes from JLH (which are unlikely) and (2) open up a world of issues regarding theft of trophies from clan vaults which would basically eliminate the attractiveness of these items.

[Azza]

(2) open up a world of issues regarding theft of trophies from clan vaults which would basically eliminate the attractiveness of these items.

dont allow people to remove them apart from the winners?

[Eamon]

Or just dont allow them to be moved at all from the trophy room. This would not only make players that have won them and have them in the trophy room possibly more loyal to their clans.....but also would stop people from having to take them out if they move to another clan.

Once a clan is stored in a trophy room, it stays there, if the clan is sold, all the trophies are deleted, like the rest of the clan house.

[Wind]

Or just dont allow them to be moved at all from the trophy room. This would not only make players that have won them and have them in the trophy room possibly more loyal to their clans.....but also would stop people from having to take them out if they move to another clan.

Once a clan is stored in a trophy room, it stays there, if the clan is sold, all the trophies are deleted, like the rest of the clan house.

Like the Idea very much

But if we put them in a room with all the others and other clannie's one's you would get mixed up on whos is whos..

[Eamon]

I dont know which idea is better....a trophy that is a personal remembrance of winning the event, or the trophy going to the clan to be put in the clan trophy room. If you give the trophies to players, they would lose their specialness quickly, as after you have so many 3 alt pt trophies, they get old and boring, would be deleted...or someone might try to buy some of them up.......

If you make it so that it could only be put directly into the clan trophy room, then its not a personal remembrance, instead it becomes an item of clan bragging rights.

Any thoughts?

[Sneaky]

Is it really that necessary? I can just see it cluttering stuff up...

[Amy]

I like this idea. Supported.

[alone]

6 new trophies a week? 312 a year. How long till these will just be left laying around cluttering the ground.
They're basicly a way around having your 'score' in your profile. These will have no value, and only serve as bragging rights. Don't the players brag enough already, without the aid of yet another item.
What of when the main contenders have 10 of these? Going to suggest another item, 'exchange 20 trophies for a plaque'..?

I'm just trying to point out the negative, as everyone's leaping at the idea.

But this idea did get me thinking about something for DS, here.

[Josh00089]

Or just dont allow them to be moved at all from the trophy room. This would not only make players that have won them and have them in the trophy room possibly more loyal to their clans.....but also would stop people from having to take them out if they move to another clan.

Once a clan is stored in a trophy room, it stays there, if the clan is sold, all the trophies are deleted, like the rest of the clan house.

Like the Idea very much

But if we put them in a room with all the others and other clannie's one's you would get mixed up on whos is whos..

make it like "so and so trophy for triplex or something"

[Da_J_Mooney]

"[Crit Name]:[Mosh Type]-[Date]"

"/view trophies"
"/view trophy [Crit Name]" or "/trophyview [Crit Name]"

And so it doesn't clutter it up, have the trophy room just say the names of the crits that have trophies:

"/view trophies"

[Crit 1]
[Crit 2]
[Crit 3]
[Crit 4]

"/view trophy [Crit 1]" or "/trophyview" [Crit 1]

[Crit 1]:[Mosh Type]-[Date]
[Crit 1]:[Mosh Type]-[Date]
[Crit 1]:[Mosh Type]-[Date]
[Crit 1]:[Mosh Type]-[Date]

Edited by Da_J_Mooney, 19 March 2006 - 07:09 PM.

[Josh00089]

not meaning to bump 10 day old posts but

anything on this? would be cool to see in game

Edited by Josh00089, 01 April 2006 - 08:03 AM.

[Deval]

A: What's to stop people selling them? Rendering their initial purpose irrelevant.

B: Clan house cry babies galore if implemented in clan houses, knowing the way you glory whorés switch clans.

C: What's the point of them being in clanhouses? So you can show off to your clanmates who already know how good you are?

D: Characters are sold and name changed so much, 5 minutes after winning a trophy, the name it's relative to would be incorrect.

E: 99% of the players are egotistical jerks as it is, to stroke their ego's any further serves no purpose.


Sounds like a rubbish waste of time to me.

Just add a mosh wins section to /who.

Edited by Deval, 01 April 2006 - 04:10 PM.